Our stated study purpose is:
The Spirit of God using the word of God to make people of God and changing the people of God into Spirit-empowered, effective, edifying, disciples of Jesus Christ.
That is not something we can do on our own, in our own strength. To think that we can accomplish that in our own strength or to attempt to do so is called legalism.
We are surrounded by laws. Laws serve a very important societal purpose; they maintain order and are the basis of convicting and controlling criminals. But some people would have us disregard laws. They are anarchists or antinomians. It is true that when we try to micromanage life with laws, it can clutter our world and overly restrict our freedoms.
When people try to live by law, things can get pretty complicated and even comical. There are many ways in our own country that people have tried to live by laws and the results have been interesting to say the least. Here are a few laws (thanks to Neil and the Facty staff) on the books of local municipalities in the United States:204
There’s humor in such laws. These are examples of laws run wild or the limits of the law.
The Law is Good, IF, You Use It Lawfully
Should we do away with the law? Should we de-fund the law? Should we live without any law (be an antinomian)? No, there is a place for law. The Bible states:
The word “lawfully” here (Greek nomimos – adverb) means legitimately, properly, agreeable to law, agreeable to the rules. If we use the law the way God the Law-Giver originally intended the law to be used, then it is “good” (Greek kalos) or beautiful, good, valuable, virtuous, excellent, useful, precious, commendable, admirable.
What are the right applications of the law?
First, the law is used by God to maintain order societally. The Bible states of God:
God created the universe and all things in an orderly manner (e.g., Genesis 1; Genesis 2). God ordered the seasons (Genesis 1:14-18; Psalm 104:19). God gave us the Law, the Ten Commandments, in a very orderly way (cf. Exodus 20 ff.; Leviticus). The Law is a tool used by God to maintain order in society.
There are laws put in place by God to govern behavior in society. God designed society to be an orderly and safe environment for people to live in. Therefore, He gave laws prohibiting parental abuse, murder, adultery, stealing, bearing false witness, and coveting what others own. These laws serve as safeguards and guardrails to keep society in order and safe. Government was later put in place by God to help with enforcing His Laws of societal order (Romans 13). The Law serves a very important purpose: to maintain order in the world.
Second, the law is used ceremonially. God instructed Moses to build a tabernacle where He would meet with Moses and the people (Exodus 25:8). Then God instructed Moses giving him laws to follow regarding how the tabernacle would be used. This use of the Law is ceremonial. The ceremonial uses of the Law do not only prescribe a certain way to use the tabernacle or approach God, they paint a picture of God’s holiness and the sacrifice of Jesus (e.g., Leviticus 1-7; Leviticus 23; John 1:29; 1 Peter 1:18-19). This is a proper use of the Law.
Third, the law tells us we should love. There is a place for the law in society. Disregarding the law can lead to a very detrimental effect. Jesus pointed this out when He said about the last days:
When God’s law is set aside and disregarded, it leads to disorder and the proliferation of sin. When we disregard, for instance, the two greatest laws:
When we disregard such law, Jesus said it leads to lovelessness. When we fail or refuse to love God and our neighbor, it leads to a much colder, heartless, hopeless, harsh world.
The Law of God and its many aspects is a tool He provides to help us govern our ways. Like any other tool, for it to be effective and useful, you must use it the way it was designed to be used. Let me illustrate.
When you wake up each day and prepare to go out, you attend to your body to make yourself presentable. The tools you use to prepare determine how well you are prepared to leave the house. What do I mean?
Are you getting the picture? For a tool to be useful, it must be matched to its intended use. Otherwise, it does more harm than good.
There is a place for law, but it’s important we use the law the way God intended it to be used. God is orderly (1 Corinthians 14:33, 40). Order is maintained by way of Law (Romans 13). But when laws and keeping them become a means to pleasing God, it’s no laughing situation.
The Spirit Acts Against Legalism, the Misuse of the Law
In the previous chapter (Acts 14) we saw how the snake Satan tries to poison seekers and the church itself with bitterness. We also saw how the grace of God provides an antidote to that poison and how the Holy Spirit strengthens the church. In Acts 15 we will see how the Holy Spirit handles the conflict which arose in the early church when believing Jews tried to add the requirement of keeping the Law to the gospel. When laws are added to the gospel and life in the Spirit, the result is legalism. The threat of legalism is something we see in the church even today, and it is a very serious threat because legalism can rob the disciple and the church of the joy of the Lord. What is legalism, and how does the Spirit act against the conflict that arises from those trying to impose legalism on the gospel of God’s grace in Christ?
The False Teaching of Legalism
One of the greatest threats to the church is legalism, or requiring something, especially laws, in addition to faith alone in Christ alone to be saved (Acts 15:1). Here those from a religious Jewish background sought to impose Mosaic customs on Gentile believers. To make circumcision a requirement for salvation would have greatly hindered the spread of the gospel as well as adopted a gospel that is based on works rather than grace. Such a “gospel” is a false gospel, a teaching that is really no gospel at all (See Matthew 5:20; Galatians; Titus 3:3-8). Works do play an important part in the life of the disciple. But works follow salvation; they are by no means necessary to precede salvation (Ephesians 2:1-9, 10). Just like Paul and Barnabus, we should oppose all attempts to add requirements to the gospel of grace, i.e., legalism (Acts 15:2; Jude 1).
The Legalistic Mindset
The Jews had been taught and believed that keeping the law obediently saved a person. They believed that if a person tried hard enough, they could keep the law. This is the attitude of the legalist. What is legalism? Legalism is thinking, “I CAN BE RIGHTEOUS BY KEEPING LAWS/RULES IF I JUST TRY HARD ENOUGH; RIGHTEOUSNESS/HOLINESS DEPENDS ON WHAT I DO.” This, as we will see, is a very flawed and frustrating way of seeking God that is also doomed to failure.
Here are some examples of a Legalistic mindset:
No matter how “righteous” the cause or “holy” we perceive the Law to be, when we try to attain righteousness or satisfaction by doing it we will always end up dissatisfied, depressed, and despairing. This reality should not lead us to nihilism or hopelessness; it should lead us to Jesus and God’s grace. Humanity in their own strength, both inside and outside of the Church, will always “fall short of the glory of God” (Romans 3:23). On our own, we always “fall short of the grace of God” (Hebrews 12:15). On our own, we don’t measure up, and we will always have a gnawing sense of something missing, emptiness.
Legalism, such as the examples above, gets the focus off of God and onto the individual. That is like taking the plug from your computer out of the wall socket and putting it in your mouth as a source of electrical power. You just don’t have what it takes to power the life of Christ; only the Spirit has that power (as we have seen in our study of Acts thus far – Acts 1:8). When we try to live righteously in our own strength by our rules, (or even good rules we take out of the Bible) we are depending on a very limited and impotent source of power that is doomed to lead us to frustration and failure in our walk with the Lord and life in general.
The Light of God in the Law
Before we look at the flaws of trying to keep laws, we should first understand the purpose God gave the Law, the light He intended to shine by way of the Law. There are seven things we need to know about the Law of God if we are to receive the light He intended the Law to bring.
First, understand that the Law of God is holy, just, and good. The Law of God has the light of life in it. When God gave the Ten Commandments, His intent was to point His people toward the way of abundant life. The Flaw that developed was not the fault of the Law; it was the fault of those who began to worship the Law instead of God the Lawgiver. In Romans, Paul says:
The flaw of the Law is not in the Law; it is in the misuse of the Law.
Second, the Law is used by God to expose our sinfulness and need of a Savior. In Romans again Paul is inspired to write:
God created human beings with a conscience that enables them to discern right from wrong (Romans 2:12-16). But so that sin might be clearly and unmistakably exposed and revealed, God gave the Law as His holy standard by which all humanity would be impartially judged (Romans 2:11). We know without a doubt that coveting is a sin because God’s Law prohibits it (Exodus 20:17). If we look at the Ten Commandments we also know that God alone is to be our God (Exodus 20:1-3); that no image, carving, statue, or idol of God or anything in heaven or on earth is to be used by those who call themselves followers of God (Exodus 20:4-6; the Roman Catholic catechism has removed this stipulation from the Ten Commandments); God’s name is not to be misused (Exodus 20:7); the Sabbath of rest unto the Lord is to be kept (Exodus 20:8-11); Parents are to be honored (Exodus 20:12); you are not to murder others (Exodus 20:13); you are not to commit adultery (Exodus 20:14); you are not to steal (Exodus 20:15); you are not to bear false witness (Exodus 20:16); and you are not to covet (Exodus 20:17). The Law exposes humanity’s utter sinfulness.
Third, the Law of God brings guilt. The Law of God in exposing our utter sinfulness brings guilt to our conscience and shows us that we are lost; we are guilty before a Holy God who will judge all justly by His Law one day. Paul puts this well when he is inspired to write:
The Law reveals to us that we are without excuse before God and stand condemned for breaking His Law.
Fourth, those who try to gain heaven by keeping the Law are required by God to keep all the Law. The Law is like a chain with links anchored in heaven with us on the other end. Break one link or Law, and you will plummet to the depths. If you are going to try to be righteous before God by keeping the Law; if, when you are asked how you will get to heaven, you respond by saying, “I will try to keep the Ten Commandments,” then you must do so flawlessly, perfectly. The Bible says this clearly in the following verses:
This truth is what the Holy Spirit convicts the world about in His efforts to lead people to Christ (John 16:8-11).
Fifth, no one can be saved from his or her sin by keeping the Law of God. Paul writes in Galatians:
Keeping the Law was never meant by God to be the means of being saved from sin; faith in God is the means to be saved from sin (Genesis 15:6; Romans 4).
Sixth,trying to keep the Law leads to bondage. The only thing that results from trying to live by Law is bondage. In his letter to the Galatians, Paul rebukes those who are trying to be law-keepers, or legalists, telling them that it only leads to bondage. He states:
When you try to live by keeping laws you end up relying on your own very limited resources and that leads to a type of bondage of futility.
Seventh, the Law of God teaches us the futility and hopelessness of trying to be righteous by keeping the Law and leads us to Christ as our means of righteousness and fulfillment. Paul writes in Romans:
The outcome of seeking righteousness in our own strength by the Law is wretchedness. The word “wretched” (Greek talaiporos) means miserable, toilsome, afflicted, overwhelmed by troubles. Trying to keep the Law or do things to be righteous only leads to hard labor and will never fulfill.
Paul writes in Galatians:
By exposing our weakness and inability to keep the Law perfectly according to God’s standards, our mouths are shut, and we stand guilty before God, forced to search outside ourselves for a way to be saved from our sins.
Eight, those who are legalists or law-keepers are under the curse of God; Jesus provides the only redemption from that curse. The Bible says:
Jesus died on the cross as a substitutionary atonement for the sins of the world (1 John 2:1-2). Jesus died in our place on the cross to pay our debt of sin and make a way for us to become righteous before God through our relationship with Him (2 Corinthians 5:21). God provides that righteousness, that forgiveness of our sin, that salvation from our sins by His grace through faith in Jesus (Ephesians 2:1-9; Titus 3:4-6). We don’t become righteous before God by working to keep the Law of God, but by acknowledging our sinfulness under God’s Law and putting our trust in Jesus as our Sin-bearer and Savior (John 1:12; John 3:16; John 5:24).
The FAITH that saved is a total and complete trust in Jesus as God’s sufficient means to atone for sin. Jesus did not pay for 99.9% of our sin, and then we have to work off the final 0.1%. Jesus paid it all; He said on the cross, “It is finished!” (John 19:30). We can define saving faith with the following acronym: Forsaking – All – I – Trust – Him. Legalism is adding to the work of Jesus. We can only be righteous based on the work of Jesus, not our works. We see this in the following inspired words of Paul, who said:
When we trust in Jesus, we are freed from the bondage of the Law.
Ninth, when a person is saved by receiving Jesus as their Savior by faith, they are filled with the Holy Spirit who gives them spiritual life and love that fulfills the Law of God. The Bible says that when a person is saved from their sin through faith in Jesus, the Holy Spirit enters them. Without the Holy Spirit within, a person is not saved from their sin. We see this in the following verses:
When a person receives Jesus as their Savior, they begin a new life in the Spirit.
When the Spirit comes to reside in a person at salvation, He pours out love into their hearts. This is what the Bible tells us in the following words:
When the Spirit pours out this love into our hearts, it completely changes the way we look at others and live.
Living in the love of the Spirit leads to the fulfilling of the Law of God in and through us. The Bible tells us:
Here we see God’s enabling power that brings about the fulfillment of the Law in us. When the love of the Spirit (see 1 Corinthians 13 and Galatians 5:22-25) fills us, and we walk in the Spirit of that love, we first love the Lord with all our heart, soul, mind, and strength (Mark 12:30). Then His love compels us in all that we do so that we no longer live for ourselves, but for Him who died for us (2 Corinthians 5:14-15). This affects us in every facet of our lives. When you love in the power of the Spirit, God becomes your Lord, your master passion, you not only have no other gods before Him, but you do not allow anything else to challenge His place in your heart and life (Exodus 20:1-3). When the love of the Spirit is working in and through you, you will sense the presence of Jesus in you and won’t need to make images or idols, not only because God has told you not to, but because you won’t need to (Exodus 20:4-6). When the love of the Spirit is in you, Jesus will be Lord of the Sabbath to you, and you can live and walk in His presence worshiping Him all the time (Exodus 20:8-11; Matthew 8:20; Mark 2:28). With the love of the Spirit in you, you will have a greater appreciation and love for your parents and a desire to see them come to the Lord as Savior too (Exodus 20:12). With the love of the Spirit in you, you won’t murder, commit adultery, steal, bear false witness or covet others’ things, because to do so would be to contradict the love of the Spirit that is in you. Do you see how the love of the Spirit fulfills the Law in your life? Just remember, it is the Lord who is working in you to bring this to pass. Rely on His strength, not your own (Philippians 1:6; Philippians 2:13)
Tenth, law-keeping or legalism is contrary to life in the Spirit. Paul rebuked the Galatians for reverting to trying to live by keeping the law. Paul tells them to be a law-keeper is to be foolish. And in light of all we’ve seen about the law, we can certainly understand that. He says:
We aren’t saved by keeping the Law because trying to keep the law in our own strength is futile; we are just not capable of doing it. Indeed, Paul writes to the Romans that when we come to Christ as our Savior, we die to the Law in that we stop trying to be righteous by keeping the Law and now depend on Christ in a new way to make us righteous before God. He says:
Legalism and law-keeping are contrary to the new life in the Spirit provided by God’s grace through faith in Jesus.
Eleventh, those who reject Christ will be judged by God on the basis of His Law. The Bible states:
The only way out from under the weight of God’s holy and just Law is through “the glorious gospel of the blessed God” which the Bible reveals to us from God.
That is the light of God in the Law, His purpose for giving the Law. What happens when the Law is misused? When the Law is misused and its original God–intended purpose misunderstood, we see the flaw of trying to keep the Law.
The Flaw of Trying to Keep the Law
Legalism, (law-keeping; trying to be righteous before God by keeping a set of rules or His Law) leads to frustration and is not an acceptable way to attain righteousness before God. Legalism leads to many problems in an individual’s walk with the Lord as well as for the body of Christ. There is a flaw in trying to keep the law to be saved. Here are just a few of those flaws.
First, legalism leads to self-righteousness. Any righteousness dependent upon what I do is self-righteousness. It depends on what I do, not what Christ has done.
Second, legalism leads to pride. People who are legalists gauge their righteousness on how they measure up to other people and how other people measure up to them. If your righteousness is based on what you do, then when you do something good, you’re going to have a boast in it. I’m going to boast about how much of the Bible I’ve read, how long I prayed today, how many souls I’ve won, how long I’ve fasted, how I wouldn’t think of drinking coffee or coke which would defile my body, etc. This is exactly what the Jews demonstrated – Romans 2:17, 23. Remember, God is opposed to the proud, but gives grace to the humble (1 Peter 5:5).
Third, legalism leads to judging. If righteousness is based on what I do, then I am going to measure others by my standard of what I think they should also do. If I can live by my standard, and you can’t, I’m going to look down at you. Those who can’t live like you are lesser than you. We see this in the Jews as well (Romans 2:1).
Fourth, legalism leads to frustration. Since legalism makes righteousness dependent upon what I do, when I inevitably fall short, I will become frustrated. If I keep the law for a day, a week, a month, a year, and then slip up, my righteousness is lost. I might think, “From now on I’m going to change.” Perhaps you will last for a period of time, but eventually you will fall. When we factor in that our thoughts as well as our actions are considered in determining righteousness by works, then we realize the impossibility of legalism. I can never be good enough in my own strength. Righteousness is not based on resolutions; it is based on God’s righteousness in Christ.
Later in this chapter, Peter explains the inevitable frustration that legalism leads to based on the past experience and history of Israel when he is inspired to say:
Legalism brings a burden a yoke of slavery. Peter tells them in no uncertain terms that the blessing and salvation they have all experienced has not been attained by keeping the law legalistically, but it has come by the grace of God. He says:
Legalism must be exposed by the gospel of God’s grace (Romans 1-8; Galatians; Ephesians 2:1-9; Titus 3:4-6).
Furthermore, have you ever told a child not to do something? They may have never even considered doing what you tell them not to do, until you tell them not to do it, and then they have to do it. The sinful fleshly nature is such that the Law incites it to disobey. The flesh is against the Spirit, against God. All you have to do to rile up the flesh is tell it God doesn’t want it to do something. When the unsaved Spiritless person tries to be righteous before God by keeping the Law, their flesh will flame up, frustrate, and lead to failure.
Fifth, legalism is impersonal; faith is personal in establishing a relationship with God in Christ. God’s law was written on stone tablets. His desire is to write them on a person’s heart. Keeping laws puts a wedge between the law-keeper and the Lawgiver, because keeping law is a work and creates a situation whereby, if the law-keeper keeps the law, the Lawgiver owes the law-keeper wages. Law short circuits God’s grace when it is not used as God intended it to be used. Legalism puts the focus on “me,” what “I,” need to do, rather than on what Jesus has done and wants to do in and through me.
Sixth,legalism is not only unspiritual, it is anti-spiritual. Paul wrote to the Galatians that you do not live by the law after your conversion:
The one who works legalistically crowds out the Spirit. Legalism focuses upon what a person must do rather than what the Spirit wants to do in and through them.
Seventh, legalism robs a person of assurance of salvation. If salvation depends upon something we must do, and if salvation depends upon something we must keep doing, and not the completed work of Christ, then when will we have done enough to know we are saved? Yes, there is to be fruit born from the conversion experience (2 Corinthians 5:17), but our salvation is not based on our works, it is Christ working in and through us to produce the fruit (Philippians 1:6; Philippians 2:12-13). If we say that Jesus has done 99% of the work of salvation and 1% is up to us to do, we are still left with the dilemma of not knowing how much is enough or when what we do will be enough to be saved. This is the plight of works righteousness religious systems. You never know how much is enough. Such systems lead to guilt and serving the Lord out of a sense of obligation rather than love (2 Corinthians 5:14-15). But when we realize that our salvation is based on the finished work of Jesus who said on the cross, “It is finished” (John 19:30), that on the cross He provided the once and for all sacrifice for sin (Hebrews 9:27-28; Hebrews 10:10, 14, 18), and that through faith alone in Him alone we can receive God’s righteousness (2 Corinthians 5:21), then and only then can we have an assurance of our salvation based on the work of Jesus.
Legalism is not God’s plan for us. God doesn’t want us to be self-righteous, spiritually proud, judgmental, frustrated, and unsure of our salvation relationship with Him. Therefore, God has provided by His grace a way in which we are righteous through Jesus, which is spiritually humbling. This leads to loving others, is effective, and provides certainty of our standing with Him. God rejects the self-effort of legalism as a means to attain righteousness before Him.
Christian Science
There is a cult called Christian Science founded by Mary Baker Eddy, but that is not the Christian Science I am referring to here. Let me explain. Science is the study of the natural universe and trying to explain it by way of formulas. Physics studies how energy produces movement; chemistry formulates how the building blocks of matter are composed. But when Christians try to explain spiritual things by way of formulas, they reduce life in the Spirit to a scientific study. That isn’t what God planned, and it isn’t the way God works. God is orderly (1 Corinthians 14:33, 40), but you cannot reduce the work of the Spirit to formulas and principles. When we try to understand the way God works by saying, when “A” is followed by “B”, then “C” always results, then we are formulizing our walk with God and that is like trying to put God in a box.
We might exemplify this by what we have seen in our study of the baptism with the Holy Spirit. We have said that the baptism with the Holy Spirit is an empowering work of the Spirit received subsequent to conversion. The disciples at Pentecost received the Holy Spirit (John 20:22) and were subsequently empowered by the baptism with the Holy Spirit (Acts 1:4-5, 8 and Acts 2:1-4). If we formulize this by saying this is the only way God works, we will have a problem when we come to Acts 10 where the Holy Spirit comes upon the believers as they heard the word preached to them by Peter (Acts 10:44-45). In Acts 10 it appears that the conversion and infilling of the believers with the Spirit is concurrent to their also being baptized with the Holy Spirit; the two works of the Spirit seem to be simultaneous. Now, if we are rigidly adherent to the initial formula of conversion and then baptism with the Spirit, then we have to explain our way around what the Spirit did. That’s not necessary when we understand that the Spirit is free to work as He pleases.
The Spirit will never contradict His word of Scripture, but He will work in ways we do not expect or ways that go beyond our limiting formulas. You can’t reduce the work of the Spirit to a science where you can map out how He will work by a set of formulas and principles. Yes, when a person repents and puts their faith in Jesus, they will be saved, but conversion happens in many ways. You don’t always have to go through the Four Spiritual Laws for a person to be saved. Sometimes a convicted criminal will simply ask the Lord to remember him, and the Lord will say, “Assuredly, I say to you, today you will be with Me in Paradise” (Luke 23:42-43). Other times, a person will receive the Lord by being told they merely have to give Him all their heart (Acts 8:37). We need to leave room for the Spirit to work. The LORD knows the heart, we do not. The Spirit works in many ways, and He is the One who determines how and when someone is saved from their sin or empowered for service.
When I received Christ as my Savior, I was in college in my room by myself one evening and had just made the long wintry trek to college. My sister had witnessed to me about my need of salvation. Up until then, I had been a religious person who chose to avoid religious conversations under the façade that religion was “private” and I didn’t want to talk about it. But the word that had been spoken to me convicted me and what I saw in my sister and her friends showed me unmistakably that I was missing something they had. On the long journey to school I had plenty of time to ponder the word of God that had been shared with me. You see, I usually had a full car of school chums but for some reason they had all canceled out on me this time, (the Spirit knew why!) When I got to my college dorm room, I shut the door and laid down on my bed. Then as I pondered and thought, it was as though the Lord told me, “Why not now, why don’t you receive Me now?” So on my bed I reached my hands to the ceiling and prayed, “Lord, if You’re real, forgive my sins, come into my heart. I want to give my life to you.” You know what? God saved my soul that evening of January 16th, 1977. Jesus changed my life completely. And I didn’t even pray the Four Spiritual Laws. All of a sudden, the word of God came alive to me (my sister had given me a Living Bible). All of a sudden, I didn’t curse anymore, (and I had previously had a real gutter mouth). I didn’t want to party anymore. No one told me it was wrong. I just knew in my heart it was not what Jesus wanted for me; the Spirit conveyed that to me. The Spirit works in ways that transcend formulas. The Spirit works in ways we don’t expect or can’t even figure out. What I have found in my walk with the Lord all these years is that most of the time all I can say to the work of the Spirit is, “Wow!” I have learned to be alert to His hand in my life and the lives of others and I pray for ears to hear Him and a heart to submit to His will.
There’s nothing wrong with taking notes and trying to order what you learn about the Lord by putting things down in an orderly fashion. But when we restrict the possibilities of how the Spirit might work according to our rigid set of formulas or rules, that is Christian Science and that is not a realistic or true way to walk in the Spirit. The Spirit works in ways we can’t even comprehend, let alone codify (John 3:8). We need to remain open and alert to the work of the Spirit and not limit Him with formulas.
Legalism Quenches Joy
The apostles didn’t let legalistic opposition rob them of the joy of what God was doing (Acts 15:3). But sometimes, opposition follows you (Acts 15:4-5). In fact, here we see the contrast between the true gospel and legalism. The Gospel of grace leads to joy; the false gospel of legalism leads to conflict. Joy is that assurance that you are in the will of God and at peace with Him, no matter the circumstances or state you are in. If you seek God based on the works of legalism, you can never have that full assurance of joy in the Spirit because you are resting on your own limited powers rather than the strength and truth of God in Christ.
The Spirit Acts to Handle Opposition in the Church
How does the Spirit resolve disputes in the church? There are five things we see done here to orchestrate the resolution of this problem, and we know it is the Spirit at work here because of the joyful conclusion that results. What are these steps to resolution?
First, He gathers the leadership (Acts 15:6). The leaders had to be willing to come together to talk and discuss the issues and differences of opinion at hand. This shows a willingness to find the heart of God in this situation. No one pouted or tried to rally a faction to their particular side of the issue.
Second, the leaders speak openly and freely about the issue at hand. Peter shared the facts (Acts 15:7-9). There was open communication. They did not speak politically or with an aim to manipulate opposition to their side, they genuinely sought the heart of God here. They began their open communication with Peter, sharing the facts of the situation.
Third, Peter contrasts God’s grace with legalism (Acts 15:10-11). Peter reminds them of the history of Israel and how they were unable to follow God legalistically. He contrasts legalism with the grace that is found in Jesus Christ, their Lord that saved them. Resolution always begins with the grace of God.
Fourth, they inspected the fruit. Barnabus and Paul shared what God had been doing through them. The blessing of God could not be denied (Acts 15:12). Jesus said that you would know His true work by the fruit it bore(Matthew 7:20; John 15:5, 8).
Fifth, they discussed the issues in an orderly manner (Acts 15:12). This was not a riot, but an orderly discussion. When the apostles stood up to testify, the others were silent and listened. God is not a God of disorder but order (1 Corinthians 14:33, 40). The presence of order is an indication that the Spirit was at work here.
Sixth, they prayed (Acts 15:13). Silence preceded a decision by James, who applied the word of God to the situation. It is safe to assume that that silence before the decision was handed down was a silence pregnant with prayer. They knew that this was a big decision that could determine the future of the church. So they prayed.
Seventh, they relied on the word of God (Acts 15:14-18). Notice James is the apostle in the highest position of authority here, not Peter. But more importantly, the decision that is arrived at through prayer is one based on the word of God. As they prayed, the Spirit must have brought a portion of Scripture to James’ mind and as he shared it, the solution to the issue at hand seemed clear. James quotes Amos 9:11-12, showing that God’s intent was to reach out to the Gentiles and so their decision must be one that would be in line with God’s desire to reach the Gentiles. That is exactly what James and the apostle decided, that Gentiles are not under the Law, but only asked to abstain from idolatry, immorality, and those dietary foods that were offensive to Jews out of respect to them (Acts 15:19-20).
Notice that this was not a democratic decision set out before the entire congregation of believers. The Spirit worked through those He had called to be leaders and then finally resolved the matter by inspiring James to make a final decision. By the time the leaders had discussed the matter, the Spirit apparently had made the final decision clear to them all (Acts 15:13-21, 28).
The Decision of the Leaders was Shared With Those it Pertained to
The decision reached in the Spirit “pleased” all those who in the Spirit sought out the will of God (Acts 15:22). Then the decision arrived at in the Spirit was communicated clearly and concisely without gray areas or vacillating to those most affected by it. They wrote the decision out in a letter, so no mistake would be made by merely using word of mouth. It is always good to put things down in writing so that there can be no mistakes or manipulation of what has been decided (Acts 15:23-26). In fact, they used the written word and word of mouth (Acts 15:27) to make things clear.
The phrase, “For it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us,….” is not a statement pronounced with pontifical authority, but is a relaying of the decision they arrived at prayerfully in the Spirit and passed on to the Gentiles. The Gentiles received it gladly as such, and when two parties are genuinely seeking the will of God in the Spirit, the decision arrived at will be abided by (Acts 15:28, 31). When those who disagree sincerely seek the Lord’s will in the Spirit and trust their spiritual leadership, the solution brings joy and a peaceful solution.
As far as the prohibitions they did pass on to the Gentiles in the Spirit, you might ask, “Aren’t those ‘Laws’ they passed on?” Rather than seeing these as laws, they seem to be more instructions to enhance the relationships between Jewish and Gentile believers. You see, if a Gentile believer invited a Jewish believer to dinner and the meat prepared was bloody or not prepared in somewhat of a kosher way, it would probably strain the conscience of the Jewish brother in the Lord and hinder fellowship. The decision is really aimed at uniting the two groups and enhancing fellowship. One commentator states:
By not attending temple banquets, or being involved in fornication, or eating meat with blood in it, the Gentile Christians would be maintaining high moral standards and would keep from offending their Jewish brothers. There were Jews in every city who would be offended by Christians not following these strictures. These Israelites were well acquainted with these moral issues.205
But apostolic instruction goes beyond courtesy towards Jewish believers too. What the apostles in the Spirit seemed to have decided was to instruct the Gentiles to avoid things that were closely linked to pagan idolatrous practices. In pagan religious practices, animal sacrifices were offered and usually with the blood having been strangled. Sexual immorality was a very common practice in pagan rituals such as temple prostitution. These things should not be a part of those calling themselves disciples of Jesus. They should refrain from such things as Paul would later instruct the Corinthians (2 Corinthians 6:11-18).
The Decision Reached in the Spirit Produced Joy
Resolution that comes from the Spirit leads to further effective ministry. When the Spirit is sought and allowed to lead in a time of disagreement or problems, the solution leads to rejoicing on both sides of the issue.
Even Spirit-Empowered Leaders Can Dispute Among Themselves
The second missionary journey starts here, but it starts with a dispute. John Mark had apparently left Paul and Barnabus prematurely during the first missionary journey (Acts 13:13). Now Paul was not ready to put ministry at risk with one who had proved unfaithful before. Barnabus was more open to giving John Mark another chance to prove himself faithful. The ministry does not seem to have been hindered in any way by this falling out between Paul and Barnabus. Two teams came from one. The Spirit actually seems to have used the situation for good. What this reveals is that Paul and Barnabus are human, and struggled at times with their flesh.
Why this disagreement? Sometimes the Spirit can use such differences. Pastor Chuck Smith makes the following insightful comment on this passage:
Now we see an interesting thing in that here are two powerful church leaders, getting in an argument, so severe that they split company. How is it that [these] men of God cannot agree? Is it possible that God wanted two missionary teams instead of one [in order to] cover twice the territory?…Because that was the net result of the contention. Barnabas took Mark and they headed off to Cypress. Paul then took Silas. They then headed off to Cilicia and…went all the way over into Europe on this journey. But God now had two teams instead of one and thus the effect of it, the overall effect of it was good, as far as the church was concerned, because it broadened their whole missionary endeavor. Now it is interesting to note that when Paul is in the final year of his life, he is writing to Timothy. He is in prison in Rome, things are not looking good. He will soon be facing Nero. And Nero is determined to persecute the Christians. Paul realizes his departure is at hand. He writes to Timothy and he says, my departure is at hand. I’ve fought a good fight and I have finished the course. I have come to the end. And I have kept the faith. But then he said to Timothy, come quickly and bring Mark with you because he will be beneficial to the ministry. So where earlier Paul had this contention because of Mark, now he is calling for Mark to come because of his benefit that he would be to Paul. Also when Paul wrote to Philemon, as he speaks of those that are with him, bringing their greetings to Philemon, he also mentions Marcus as one who was there with him, sending his greeting. So the differences that did exist were ultimately patched up. God still had the two missionary teams instead of one. So God can sometimes use differences of opinion, disputes, He can use them to further the overall work of the gospel, as was the case here.206
The Spirit can even use our deficiencies to further His work.
Conclusion
Below are some more laws that were either once on the books of local municipalities or still are on the books of municipalities throughout the country.
Now all of these laws may have seemed important at the time they were first made, but now they have lost all serious value (except maybe for the barbers not eating onions between 7 a.m. and 7 p.m.!) and have become obsolete and even comical. We laugh at such laws but don’t we do the same thing when we bring legalism into the church? Do you really think you will make a person holy or righteous by trying to impose on them the outside laws and rules? The Bible tells us it just won’t work. Wouldn’t a better strategy be to encourage life in the Spirit where living in the love of the Spirit by the grace of God is encouraged?
If you have the Spirit and His love is in you, you just may be more conscious of not offending others with your bad breath if you are a barber. Now I don’t know if having the love of the Spirit in you will prevent you from carrying ice cream in your pocket or eating peanuts in church, or washing two babies in the same tub at the same time, or giving cigars to cats and dogs, or making sure your clothes match before you go outside, or stop you from taking a lion to the movies or walking across the street on your hands, or refraining from the other things mentioned above. With the Spirit in you, you just may want to break that Oklahoma law that says you can’t share your hamburger, or you may even be moved to buy some doughnut holes! A pastor like me might even be moved to use a bit of humor in his message. But one thing I am sure of: with the Spirit in you and His love, you will fulfill His Law by His grace the way He intended it to be fulfilled. That’s the most important way to see the light of God in the Law.
204 Insane US Laws You Won’t Believe Exist by Neil, Facty Staff, April 21, 2020 – https://facty.com/network/answers/culture/insane-us-laws-you-wont-believe-exist/3/
205 John F. Walvoord, and Roy B. Zuck, The Bible Knowledge Commentary, (Wheaton, Illinois: Scripture Press Publications, Inc.) 1983, 1985.
206 Chuck Smith, Word For Today audiotape #8104 (P.O. Box 8000, Costa Mesa CA 92628)
207 Campus Life, March, 1973.
The Blue Letter Bible ministry and the BLB Institute hold to the historical, conservative Christian faith, which includes a firm belief in the inerrancy of Scripture. Since the text and audio content provided by BLB represent a range of evangelical traditions, all of the ideas and principles conveyed in the resource materials are not necessarily affirmed, in total, by this ministry.
Loading
Loading
Interlinear |
Bibles |
Cross-Refs |
Commentaries |
Dictionaries |
Miscellaneous |